Justice

Former attorney general contests €39,009 costs bill

Former attorney general contests €39,009 costs bill RUSSPAIN.com © russpain.com
Former attorney general contests €39,009 costs bill © russpain.com
Álvaro García Ortiz is asking the Supreme Court to cut the costs awarded to Alberto González Amador from €39,009 to €4,240. His appeal disputes charges for work it says was unnecessary or already excluded.

Alberto González Amador sought four years in prison and a €108,000 fine. The Supreme Court imposed no prison term and fined him €7,200. It also awarded him €10,000 for moral damage, far below the €300,000 sought by his private prosecution.

That gap lies at the heart of former attorney general Álvaro García Ortiz’s appeal against the costs decree. The State Legal Service is asking the Supreme Court’s Criminal Chamber to reduce the amount payable for González Amador’s lawyer and procuradora from €39,009 to €4,240. That is a reduction of €34,769, or about 89.1%. elDiario.es reported it had obtained the appeal.

The appeal argues that the costs assessment failed to account for the gap between the private prosecution’s demands and the final sentence. The court convicted García Ortiz under the basic offence in Article 417.1 of the Criminal Code, not the aggravated form in Article 417.2 on which González Amador had relied. The sentence included a fine and disqualification. On 20 November 2025, the Supreme Court announced García Ortiz’s conviction for revealing confidential information connected with González Amador, the partner of Madrid regional president Isabel Díaz Ayuso. It imposed a €7,200 fine, two years’ disqualification from serving as state prosecutor general and €10,000 in compensation to González Amador. The full reasoning followed on 9 December.

The State Legal Service separately puts the approved fees at €38,500, equivalent to 385.08% of the €10,000 civil award. It also objects to how the assessment treated work on appeals for reform and appeal, as well as reconsideration. Fees for certain filings were excluded because costs in most of those proceedings had been declared payable by each party. Yet the work was later cited as evidence of the case’s complexity. The dispute is about the detailed assessment of recoverable costs, not a fresh ruling on García Ortiz’s criminal liability.

The appeal challenges several individual charges. They include €756.54 for a motion for reform that González Amador’s private prosecution withdrew the day after filing, €183.73 for requesting technical access to the Horus judicial platform and €367.46 for a one-page request for Word-file metadata. The appeal says both the investigating judge and the Supreme Court rejected that last request.

It also disputes €2,377.14 for two sets of provisional conclusions, each charged at €1,188.57. The second filing was almost identical to the first; it removed only the name of Pilar Rodríguez, then Madrid’s senior prosecutor, who was cleared in the case.

The appeal cites the Colegio de Abogados de Alcalá de Henares’ expert assessment of the bill. Its guidelines call for maximum moderation in setting fees. The appeal says the decree did not address each objection individually, relying instead on general references to the size of the case and García Ortiz’s institutional position. A separate court proceeding involving a public figure is covered in our report on Felipe González’s paternity case.

García Ortiz asks the Criminal Chamber to set the fees at €4,240 under the State Legal Service’s itemised calculation, or choose a proportionate sum. He also seeks to pause payment until the dispute is resolved. The appeal says there is no risk of non-payment: he continues to serve as Fiscal de Sala at the Supreme Court and has provided a unilateral mortgage as security for the claimed amount.

Richard Reid RUSSPAIN.com
Editor

Richard Reid

Richard Reid is the News Editor at RUSSPAIN.COM. He oversees editorial standards, source review and corrections and writes across general news, including politics, economics and social affairs.