Justice

PSOE withholds lawyer brief details from judge in caso Cloacas

PSOE withholds lawyer brief details from judge in caso Cloacas RUSSPAIN.com © russpain.com
PSOE withholds lawyer brief details from judge in caso Cloacas © russpain.com
The party gave the National Court a list of lawyers and invoices but withheld the purpose of each assignment. Separately, a Teruel judge sent the Forestalia investigation to join the caso Cloacas.

Investigators in caso Cloacas are examining whether lawyers were hired to advance and fund Leire Díez’s alleged efforts to weaken court cases damaging to the PSOE and the prime minister. The party has given the National Court a list of its lawyers and invoices, while withholding details of what each assignment involved. The inquiry is also examining whether legal-service contracts were genuine professional assignments or could have channelled money connected to the alleged operation.

In a filing to judge Santiago Pedraz, the PSOE says it supplied an Excel table listing each assignment, the territory or federation that commissioned it, the law firm, the fee and a generic service category. It also submitted invoices showing the amounts, dates, tax details and billed concepts. The records cover lawyers and firms hired between 2021 and 2025 and were delivered on 18 November in three boxes of paper documents and on a USB drive. The PSOE says it has met the court’s request.

The dispute is over whether those records reveal confidential legal work. The PSOE says matching a firm with the commissioning body, date and amount could identify who received advice and for what purpose, potentially exposing clients’ privacy and political affiliation. Its position draws on professional-secrecy guidance from the Consejo General de la Abogacía Española (CGAE), including the principle that when the party pays for work but is not the ultimate client, the client and lawyer should be identified and heard before disclosure. It asked Pedraz to keep the material from the popular accusations; the judge granted the request, leaving access at that stage to the Anti-Corruption Prosecutor’s Office while it examines the documents.

Limits of legal privilege

The party’s filing relies on guidance from the Consejo General de la Abogacía Española (CGAE), which distinguishes between types of legal records. It describes protection as strongest for lawyers’ reports and written submissions, partial for engagement letters, contracts and invoices, and inapplicable to identifying and financial data. The guidance says a lawyer’s identity need not be accompanied by a description of the assignment. The PSOE argues, however, that the combination of a lawyer’s identity, commissioning body, date, fee and generic service description could indirectly reveal the purpose of legal advice.

If Pedraz seeks details about a particular assignment, the PSOE asks that the request be made individually. The party says it would then notify the lawyers concerned and, where relevant, the people they represented so they could consent or state their position.

Two lawyers hired by the party, Jacobo Teijelo and Ismael Oliver, have already been placed under investigation in caso Cloacas. Reporting on the inquiry says Oliver is being examined over whether companies associated with him were used as a route for payments allegedly destined for Díez; Teijelo reportedly represented Santos Cerdán while also invoicing the PSOE for legal services. Pedraz is examining whether other contracts may have concealed payments intended for Díez, and whether the same method was used in other assignments. The investigation is ongoing, and the allegations do not amount to a final finding of wrongdoing by the PSOE or the lawyers. A separate investigation into PSOE financing had also led the UCO to seek donation records from Spain’s audit court, as reported in an earlier donation inquiry.

Forestalia proceedings sent to Madrid

Separately, the judge in Teruel handling the Forestalia case agreed to send its proceedings to the Audiencia Nacional for inclusion in caso Cloacas. Pedraz was already investigating alleged criminal conduct by Díez within the Sepi, including activity linked to Forestalia. The Teruel judge reportedly considered the Forestalia operations connected to the Ferraz-linked network and the “red Hirurok,” described in reporting as involving Díez and former PSOE Organization Secretary Santos Cerdán, among others.

The Teruel judge’s decision rests on the focus of the environmental prevarication investigation: the Ministerio de Transición Ecológica y el Reto Demográfico and, to a lesser extent, the Instituto Nacional de Gestión Ambiental de Aragón (Inaga). The suspected decision favouring Forestalia is alleged to have been made in Madrid and Zaragoza.

Lara Carter RUSSPAIN.com
Journalist

Lara Carter

Lara Carter is a journalist at RUSSPAIN.COM covering Spanish current affairs, culture, tourism, transport, economy and society.