News

Credit Acceptance faces record payout over doomed car loans

Credit Acceptance faces record payout over doomed car loans RUSSPAIN.com © russpain.com
Credit Acceptance faces record payout over doomed car loans © russpain.com
Credit Acceptance Corporation will pay 694 million dollars after being accused of knowingly approving car loans that many borrowers could never repay. The deal includes cash compensation and debt forgiveness for affected customers.

Credit Acceptance Corporation will pay 694 million dollars to settle claims that it knowingly approved car loans set up to fail. The agreement includes cash payments and debt forgiveness for thousands of borrowers, wrapping up a sweeping investigation led by 41 attorneys general from across the United States. State officials call it one of the largest settlements ever in auto lending, addressing years of complaints about predatory practices.

The states say Credit Acceptance built its business around risky loans, using its own risk scores to approve used car loans even when its calculations showed many customers would default. In some cases, the company knew the principal would never be repaid, yet pushed the loans through. High interest rates left buyers without their cars and still carrying debt. State regulators found the company routinely approved loans with a high chance of default, affecting tens of thousands of people nationwide.

Roughly 55,000 consumers are expected to benefit from the settlement through cash payments and debt relief distributed across participating states. Of the total, 60 million dollars will go directly to consumers, while 634 million dollars will come as debt relief: 388 million for people whose cars have been repossessed and 246 million for those still making payments. The company will also pay 15 million dollars to the states. State authorities say the money will be managed so current and former borrowers receive compensation or debt forgiveness, depending on their loan status.

For many drivers, the fallout was severe. Missing a few payments could mean losing a car, after which collectors pursued the remaining balance. Often, the car sold at auction for less than the amount owed. In this system, loan approval did not mean the borrower could afford the car; it meant the lender had calculated how much it was willing to lose. State officials say this approach trapped many low-income borrowers in a cycle of debt. Some owed large sums even after losing their vehicles.

Credit Acceptance also allowed dealers to bundle extras such as service agreements and GAP coverage. Some buyers did not know these products were optional; others were told they were required. The add-ons increased monthly payments and extended loan terms, making risky loans even harder to pay off.

The new rules take effect on 2 November 2026. Credit Acceptance must give borrowers clearer warnings about default risks and the car’s actual value, while keeping closer watch on add-on sales. For certain cars, the financed amount is capped at 109% of market value. Some borrowers with the riskiest loans, which failed quickly, could have up to 95% of their debt wiped out. The company or a claims administrator will contact those eligible. State documents say the deal takes full effect only after court approval and consent judgments in each state. The settlement also requires clearer disclosures about default risks and stricter oversight of add-on product sales. Several states have published estimates of their share of the relief.

This case highlights a basic problem in used car lending: lenders often earn money from interest when they approve a loan, rather than ensuring the borrower can pay. As reported earlier, for many dealers and lenders, the real profit is in financing, not the car.

The story is American, but the warning travels. In Spain, for example, lenders must disclose the total cost of credit and the annual percentage rate. Aggressive financing and bundled extras remain common in the used car market. Buyers should get a written breakdown of the total credit cost and check every included product, along with their rights to remove or cancel add-ons. Consumer protection agencies and the Bank of Spain can help if something seems wrong.

This settlement is rare. It shows what can happen when lenders treat risk as a numbers game instead of a duty to lend responsibly. The new rules and debt relief may help some borrowers, but the industry’s basic incentives have not changed. Anyone considering financing a used car should remember that approval does not mean they can afford it; the real cost may be hidden in the fine print.

Frank Miller RUSSPAIN.com
Editor

Frank Miller

Frank Miller covers the automotive industry, transport and Spanish road regulation for RUSSPAIN.COM