Scandals

Vox pulls video after backlash over self-employed workers

Vox pulls video after backlash over self-employed workers RUSSPAIN.com © russpain.com
Vox pulls video after backlash over self-employed workers © russpain.com
A video posted by Vox shows its economic spokesman asking a business owner which collective agreement applies. The owner says two workers are off sick and registered as autónomos; the party removed the clip after criticism.

In the video, José María Figaredo asks a business owner which collective agreement covers his activity. The man says he does not know. Independent reporting identified the businessman as associated with Serbrico Hogar SL.

Asked about his employees, the owner says he has two workers off sick and that they are registered as autónomos. He tells Figaredo he cannot call them while they are off. He says they are self-employed because, as he put it, nowadays it is not possible to hire people. Figaredo replies that people who hire staff later regret it.

Vox posted the clip on social media to defend small business owners and self-employed workers. After a day on X, the party deleted it following criticism over the apparent employment irregularity. The exchange also drew criticism because the owner described two people as unavailable due to illness while saying they were registered as self-employed rather than hired employees.

The criticism centres on whether the workers should have been employees rather than self-employed contractors. In Spain, the distinction depends on how work is actually carried out: whether the worker operates within another party’s organization and direction, or organizes the work independently and assumes business risk. A person formally registered with the Special Regime for Self-Employed Workers (RETA) may still be considered an employee if the actual working relationship is subordinate. The video records the owner’s account, but it does not establish a legal finding. The comments describe a dispute over workers’ status, not a ruling by an authority. Spain also recognizes economically dependent self-employed workers, or TRADE. Under Article 11 of the Statute of Self-Employment, at least 75% of relevant income must come from one client, subject to statutory conditions. Having one client alone does not establish false self-employment. The assessment considers who controls the work and supplies equipment, as well as commercial risk and contact with the final customer. Collective agreements are also central to a separate wage-policy report on a proposal by Toni Valero.

Eduardo Abad, president of the progressive self-employed association UPTA, accused the owner of using false self-employment and called the situation serious. He also criticised Vox for presenting the exchange as an example of the Spain the party wants to govern.

Hugo Martínez Abarca, a Más Madrid MP, said the owner was complaining that he could not put pressure on workers when they were ill. Carolina Alonso, a former regional Podemos MP, also described the workers as false autónomos and called the business owner a tax defaulter. Their remarks were political criticism; the video itself was not an official finding by a labour authority.

Richard Reid RUSSPAIN.com
Editor

Richard Reid

Richard Reid is the News Editor at RUSSPAIN.COM. He oversees editorial standards, source review and corrections and writes across general news, including politics, economics and social affairs.