Politics and Politicians

Argüello fails to win bishops’ election statement

Argüello fails to win bishops’ election statement RUSSPAIN.com © russpain.com
Argüello fails to win bishops’ election statement © russpain.com
Luis Javier Argüello García’s bid for a formal election note exposed divisions at the bishops’ autumn plenary. He sought to restore a practice his two immediate predecessors had abandoned.

The bishops had six substantial matters on the autumn plenary agenda when their president sought to add an electoral declaration. The Spanish Episcopal Conference’s 130th Plenary Assembly met in Madrid from 16 to 20 November, during the campaign for Spain’s 29 November general election. When he opened the assembly on 16 November, Luis Javier Argüello García declined to address the election directly. He said he hoped the bishops could issue a collective statement instead.

He left without the formal note he wanted. Reports on 18 and 19 November said the proposal was blocked in an internal vote, failing to reach the two-thirds threshold required for publication. The account described the result as a defeat for Argüello, though it remained unclear whether the final communiqué would include a brief electoral reference. That uncertainty concerned the communiqué, not a standalone note. The failed bid would have marked the first national electoral guidance from the bishops since October 2011, roughly 15 years earlier.

The dispute revived a practice the bishops had already dropped. During the presidencies of Ricardo Blázquez, from 2014 to 2020, and Juan José Omella, from 2020 to 2024, the conference refrained from issuing comparable national voting guidance.

Antonio María Rouco issued electoral notes during his presidencies from 1999 to 2005 and from 2008 to 2014. Ricardo Blázquez led the Conference Episcopal from 2005 to 2008, then again from 2014 to 2020. Juan José Omella, president from 2020 to 2024, also abandoned the custom. Such statements often proved difficult to agree on and had limited influence, according to the account. At times, they said no party deserved Catholic voters’ support. On other occasions, they challenged laws that allied parties were unwilling to repeal.

Argüello has criticised what he sees as his predecessors’ political caution. He has argued that Parliament lacks Catholic voices and that earlier bishops acted in a political rather than apostolic mode. The account links that view to Vicente Enrique y Tarancón, whom some church figures blamed for opposing efforts to create a Catholic party in 1977. The bishops did not honour Tarancón for his prominent presidencies, even on the centenary of his birth.

The divisions do not fall neatly along conservative and liberal lines. Most bishops are conservative. The account estimated that about 20% were close to Vox. Most others were on the right represented by PP. It also described a small social-democratic current, often concealed, alongside nationalist prelates.

Argüello had recently devoted several pages to the address León XIV delivered to a joint session of the Cortes Generales on 8 June. The bishops’ conference published the speech, which received seven minutes of applause. León XIV challenged laws passed by centrist and left-wing governments since 1977, including divorce legislation. He also addressed abortion and euthanasia. His criticisms extended to education policy and the handling of historical memory. He also questioned democratic standards, corruption and polarisation.

Argüello’s own remarks sharpened the contrast. In his 16 November opening address, he criticised polarising rhetoric, including what he called “hysterical aggression.” He also condemned political language that casts opponents as enemies in an “us or them” divide. At a summer school organised by the Conference Episcopal and Fundación Pablo VI from 7 to 9 July under the title El colapso de la democracia, he invoked san Agustín’s account of a state that abandons ethics. He condemned the conduct of political leaders. Weeks earlier, he had called for early elections.

The election debate also drew proposals from outside the Church. A separate RUSSPAIN.COM report covered lawyers’ election demands on justice reform.

Richard Reid RUSSPAIN.com
Editor

Richard Reid

Richard Reid is the News Editor at RUSSPAIN.COM. He oversees editorial standards, source review and corrections and writes across general news, including politics, economics and social affairs.