Justice

ICAM presses parties on justice reforms before 29 November vote

ICAM presses parties on justice reforms before 29 November vote RUSSPAIN.com © russpain.com
ICAM presses parties on justice reforms before 29 November vote © russpain.com
The ICAM presented 60 measures to representatives of the PP and PSOE, as well as Vox and Frente Amplio, at a forum 11 days before the 29 November election. It warned that mandatory MASC rules and unchanged IPREM thresholds risk limiting access to justice.

The ICAM says 84% of lawyers reject making the appropriate means of dispute resolution (MASC) compulsory. At its forum on 18 November, the Madrid Bar Association also said most lawyers had given Organic Law 1/2025 a zero rating during its first months in force. Published in the Boletín Oficial del Estado on 3 January 2025, the law made an attempt at an appropriate dispute-resolution process a precondition for many civil and commercial claims, subject to statutory exceptions. The requirement became operational in April 2025: parties must show that negotiations were attempted, but need not have reached an agreement.

The college presented 60 measures to representatives from the PP and PSOE, as well as Vox and Frente Amplio, 11 days before the general election on 29 November. Its dean, Eugenio Ribón, said the law was operating as an obstacle to access to justice and called for an assessment of the new Tribunales de Instancia, part of the law’s reorganization of the courts. PSOE representative Rafael Simancas defended the reform as a modernization measure and said the new courts could help distribute workloads. Ribón also urged parties to tackle court delays and technology failures, with cancelled hearings among the day-to-day problems. In the ICAM survey, 84% opposed compulsory MASC; the figures reflect lawyers’ views rather than official case-processing data.

A separate concern is the possible effect of the latest rise in the minimum wage on access to free legal aid. The Consejo de Ministros approved an increase that will bring the annual SMI to €18,004 in 2027, while the IPREM used to set eligibility thresholds remains unchanged. Ribón warned that people on modest incomes could lose eligibility if their earnings exceed the existing limits; the ICAM is calling for the thresholds to be updated.

The college also wants a two-year plan to raise legal aid fees by 35% and pay for every professional service carried out. It is also seeking a specific status for lawyers working on the service. The parties differed over how to proceed. The PP’s María Jesús Moro called for a new legal aid law and urgent changes to MASC, particularly in family and minors’ cases. Simancas cited an average 8% increase in payments for legal-aid work managed by the Justice Ministry, rising to 10% in some proceedings, including certain uncontested family matters, and pledged to pursue new legislation in the next term. Updated fee schedules also set MASC payments: an agreement can attract 125% of the applicable procedural amount, while an unsuccessful MASC intervention is paid at €32.40. Vox’s Marta Castro said the increase was insufficient. Miguel Montejo of Frente Amplio argued for universal access to legal protection.

Delays in the social courts are another target of the ICAM’s proposals. Its plan seeks to cut the number of cases more than two years old in that jurisdiction by between 30% and 50%, through measures including more staff and better enforcement of judgments. The college has also called for payment of all legal aid work performed.

Ribón raised concerns about graduates still waiting for the second 2026 sitting of the bar entrance exam, saying the delay was leaving their entry into the profession uncertain. He also pressed for the pending regulations governing the route from alternative mutual funds to the RETA. All four parties addressed the issue: PSOE’s Simancas promised swift implementation, while the PP’s Moro said her party would develop the rules promptly if it entered government. Vox’s Castro called for the mechanism to include retired mutual members excluded from the approved arrangement.

The wider campaign has also featured party positions on migration and household costs, as set out in an earlier campaign report. At the ICAM forum, the parties also disagreed over judicial governance: Vox wants judges and magistrates to elect the 12 judicial members of the Consejo General del Poder Judicial, while Simancas defended parliamentary election. Montejo called for public procedures and reasoned decisions.

Richard Reid RUSSPAIN.com
Editor

Richard Reid

Richard Reid is the News Editor at RUSSPAIN.COM. He oversees editorial standards, source review and corrections and writes across general news, including politics, economics and social affairs.