Justice

Spain's Constitutional Court overturns Fonsi Loaiza conviction

Spain's Constitutional Court overturns Fonsi Loaiza conviction RUSSPAIN.com © russpain.com
Spain's Constitutional Court overturns Fonsi Loaiza conviction © russpain.com
The Constitutional Court has quashed the €2,100 fine imposed on Fonsi Loaiza over posts linking Mame Mbaye’s death to municipal police. It ruled that the messages formed part of a political debate on human rights and migration.

Mame Mbaye was 35 when he collapsed in Madrid’s Lavapiés neighbourhood while being pursued by municipal police during an operation targeting street vendors. A later investigation closed the case after identifying cardiac ischaemia as the cause of the cardiorespiratory arrest that killed him. Mbaye, a Senegalese street vendor, died in March 2018, and his death prompted protests and public debate over police enforcement against street sellers.

On 19 November 2026, Spain’s Constitutional Court overturned the €2,100 fine imposed on Alfonso 'Fonsi' Loaiza for posts about Mbaye’s death. The full court granted Loaiza constitutional protection and annulled the conviction, along with the subsequent decisions. Madrid Criminal Court No. 20 had imposed the fine on 12 October 2021; the Madrid Provincial Court upheld the conviction, and a 2023 decision declined to admit a further cassation challenge. The plenary ruling passed by eight votes to three, with three judges issuing dissenting opinions.

Loaiza had linked Mbaye’s death to the police operation in posts published on Twitter on 15 and 16 March 2018. A police union complained about one post, and Madrid courts convicted him of serious insults against the municipal police. The Madrid Provincial Court reasoned that his use of the word “murder” accused officers of killing Mbaye with deliberate cruelty or for reward, and found that the posts harmed the police’s dignity and reputation.

The Constitutional Court read the posts in a different context. In a judgment prepared by magistrate Ramón Sáez Valcárcel, it said they addressed the State and police as institutions, not the personal honour of identifiable officers. Their central element, the court held, was an opinion on migration policy and the policing of street vending, rather than the narration of a homicide. It described the posts as an exercise of freedom of criticism in a public debate about state immigration policy. Because the messages were political opinions, the court said the lower courts should not have applied the truthfulness test used for freedom of information.

The ruling also faulted the lower courts for assessing Loaiza chiefly as a journalist reporting facts rather than as a citizen expressing an opinion. It treated his posts as political commentary that placed Mbaye’s death in the wider context of migration enforcement and informal street vending. The court’s reasoning distinguishes criticism of public authorities from a personal attack on a named individual. It requires courts to consider the target and political context of comparable statements.

The decision followed arguments from the prosecution supporting Loaiza’s appeal. His lawyer, Sonia Olivella, said the conviction could deter people from criticising police institutions on social media, even when they did not attack individual officers’ honour. The Constitutional Court noted that judgments from the European Court of Human Rights had prompted a review of its doctrine, which drew on decisions dating back to the late 1980s.

One earlier example involved conscientious objector José Luis Navazo, whose conviction over an ironic article about judges was overturned. The court held that context protected his freedom of expression, despite describing his opinion as harsh, inaccurate and unfair. This ruling concerns expression rights; a separate legal-costs appeal involving a former attorney general concerns fees before the Supreme Court.

Richard Reid RUSSPAIN.com
Editor

Richard Reid

Richard Reid is the News Editor at RUSSPAIN.COM. He oversees editorial standards, source review and corrections and writes across general news, including politics, economics and social affairs.