News

Judge Extends Dana Flood Investigation in Valencia Until 2027

Judge Extends Dana Flood Investigation in Valencia Until 2027 RUSSPAIN.com © russpain.com
Judge Extends Dana Flood Investigation in Valencia Until 2027 © russpain.com
The criminal probe into the management of the Dana flood in Valencia will continue for at least six more months. The court cites unresolved witness statements and forensic reports as reasons for the extension. The case now stretches into 2027.

A court in Catarroja has ordered the investigation into how authorities handled the Dana flood disaster in Valencia to remain open until at least April 2027. The court cited the case’s complexity and the volume of unresolved evidence as it extended the inquiry into one of the region’s most closely watched crises.

Judge Nuria Ruiz Tobarra, who leads the inquiry, said the seriousness of the case and the number of pending actions make a quick resolution impossible. The court’s latest order, supported by prosecutors, cites outstanding statements from witnesses and victims, along with basic forensic reports that remain incomplete. The original deadline was October 30, but the court now considers that date unworkable. EFE reports that investigators are also weighing whether to add up to eight more possible victims, which could raise the official death toll from 232 to 240, depending on the final forensic findings.

Judge Ruiz has already increased the official death toll to 232 after recognizing a new victim linked to an oxygen supply failure.
Costablanca FM

One of the most disputed issues is whether investigators can recover messages from José Manuel Cuenca, the former chief of staff to ex-president Carlos Mazón. The communications from the day of the Dana flood have not been retrieved, though the court has not ruled out the possibility. The outcome could shape the direction of the case. Democrata and other Spanish media have reported that the inability to access the messages remains a major obstacle to the investigation.

Beyond digital evidence, the court is still waiting for several affected people and witnesses to testify. Their statements could prompt further medical and forensic reviews, especially as the investigation considers whether more deaths should be officially linked to the disaster. The judge has not ruled out recognizing additional victims if new information comes to light. EFE reports that the final number of victims remains uncertain as the court awaits forensic reports on eight open cases.

Not every claim has been accepted. In a recent decision, the court rejected a request to classify the death of a 93-year-old woman from La Torre as a direct result of the Dana flood. She died in November 2024 after slipping on mud in her home and later suffering a heart attack. Forensic analysis found that her death was mainly due to pre-existing severe cardiovascular and systemic conditions, not injuries from the flood’s aftermath.

Judge Ruiz has also criticized the defense's arguments, particularly its position on the Es-Alert emergency message, which was sent only at 20:11 and was considered too late and lacking in content. The court has refused to request the voluntary handover of communications from Pilar Bernabé for October 29, 2024, emphasizing that Pradas and Argueso were responsible for monitoring local risks.
El Español

The extension comes as Spanish courts face pressure to clarify responsibility in high-profile cases involving public safety and government response. Other legal proceedings in Spain have also slowed amid procedural hurdles and the need for thorough evidence. As reported earlier, major investigations have been delayed by the volume of documentation and the difficulty of securing basic testimony.

For residents of Valencia and the wider Comunitat Valenciana, the court’s decision means continued uncertainty over who, if anyone, will be held responsible for management failures during the Dana flood. The drawn-out timeline reflects the seriousness of the allegations and the limits of Spain’s judicial system when dealing with complex, multi-victim disasters. The court says it will not rush the process to avoid superficial justice, but the delay also highlights the frustration of those still waiting for answers.

Richard Reid RUSSPAIN.com
Editor

Richard Reid

Richard Reid is the News Editor at RUSSPAIN.COM. He oversees editorial standards, source review and corrections and writes across general news, including politics, economics and social affairs.